This review is by request. At the gym, one of the TVs was showing a commercial for Wendy’s Pretzel Bacon Pub Cheeseburger, and my trainer said “you should do a burger review of that.” (People seem to like the burger reviews; I was having lunch at a restaurant after visiting the shooting range a while back, and a woman recognized me and asked when I was going to do another burger review. Well, here you go, ma’am!)
It sounded pretty good. It’s basically a Wendy’s single with a pretzel bun, bacon, beer cheese sauce, Munster cheese, honey mustard, crispy fried onions, and pickles. Sounded good, and as it happened the next day I was heading home from a late class and picked one up.
Bottom line, the whole was less than the sum of the parts. It sounded good, but in practice it was meh, even though the one I got was clearly fresh and hot.
The first bite was pretty good — lots of applewood bacon and just a hint of the sauce. I’m not actually crazy about pretzel buns, but this one wasn’t overdone (my own opinion of buns is that they shouldn’t have a strong character of their own but should let the meat, cheese, and toppings dominate). But the further I got into it, the more disappointed I was. The beer cheese, which should have been a highlight, was basically just salty. I couldn’t taste the honey mustard at all. The meat was fine — Wendy’s has good meat — but the Munster cheese had less flavor than the usual American that goes with a standard Wendy’s. I couldn’t tell that the onions or pickles were there at all as they were overwhelmed by the saltiness of the beer cheese. The end result was a burger that was kinda salty but otherwise had little in the way of special flavor.
Maybe I just got a bad one, but as I say it seemed like the burger I got was fresh, and a standard production. I love beer cheese — back when the Blackhorse Saloon here used to have a location near us, I got them to replace the hollandaise on their eggs benedict with beer cheese once when they were out of hollandaise, and it was so good the staff started having them that way all the time. But this beer cheese just wasn’t up to that standard.
This was a 760 calorie burger, about 150 calories more than the “Son of Baconator” that is my usual drive-through go-to at Wendy’s. (The Son of Baconator is 630 calories; the full Baconator is 960, which is still less than the Wendy’s Triple with Cheese, which clocks in at 1160 and which was my standard Wendy’s lunch, along with a large fries, when I used to order them in college. And I somehow weighed like 160 pounds back then. . . . Sigh.)
The Son of Baconator never disappoints; the Pretzel Bacon Pub Cheeseburger did. I’m putting it down to quality of ingredients — I just don’t think they brought their “A” game to the beer cheese, and I don’t know if I got shorted on the honey mustard or not but none of the other ingredients had enough flavor to hold up next to the salty-yet-uninspired beer cheese.
Well, they can’t all be gems. Weigh in in the comments on what I should review next? Hardee’s? Whataburger? Culver? Let me know.
And if you enjoy these essays please take out a paid subscription. It’s much appreciated when you do.





Perfesser- Well, dang. I was pulling for Wendys. Sorry they missed the mark.
Keep them reviews coming!
The pictures are less appetizing than the review. Glad I make my own pretzel rolls.